Don’t spend money on fortune‑telling, tarot, or astrology to make decisions
There is a classic classroom experiment: students are given 'personality analyses' that are actually identical for everyone, yet most people find them remarkably accurate. This is precisely why fortune-telling seems accurate. An astrologer's success rate in picking correctly is about the same as random guessing. The cost is more than just a few dozen yuan: a fortune-telling gang in Xixian, Henan, collected 'incense money' and 'offering packages' of up to 3888 yuan, and the ringleader was sentenced to eleven years in prison.
It costs nothing. The hard part is giving up a quick short…
Classic classroom experiment: after a personality test, students got a “personal analysis” that was identical…
It costs nothing. The hard part is giving up a quick shortcut for making choices and having to think for yourself afterward.
Classic classroom experiment: after a personality test, students got a “personal analysis” that was identical for everyone, yet most rated it as accurate. The author’s conclusion is that “acceptance by the subject or the analyst does not prove the explanation is correct.” Of 39 students scoring accuracy from 0 to 5, 34 gave 4 or 5. From the table distribution, the mean is about 4.26. That explains why fortune-telling always seems accurate — the Barnum effect. Astrology was also tested double-blind; the result was published in Nature. Astrologers had to pick, from three personality profiles, the one that matched a chart. They picked correctly in 40 of 116. Blind guessing would hit about 38.5; the astrologers had expected to hit 58.5. Official case: the Xixian County procuratorate in Henan reported an online fortune-telling fraud ring that first drew people in with free palm reading, then charged “incense money” and “offering packages” up to 3888 yuan. Over 50 victims; more than 2000000 yuan recovered; the lead defendant got 11 years’ imprisonment and a 100000 yuan fine.
Forer BR (1949). The fallacy of personal validation: A classroom demonstration of gullibility. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 44(1):118-123(表 1 评分分布:2 分 1 人、3 分 4 人、4 分 18 人、5 分 16 人,N=39). https://doi.org/10.1037/h0059240;Carlson S (1985). A double-blind test of astrology. Nature 318:419-425(表 2:首选 116 份,挑中 40 份,随机期望 38.5,占星师预计 58.5;「The data are consistent with chance, inconsistent with astrological hypothesis」). https://doi.org/10.1038/318419a0,Richard Muller 网站收录的全文副本 https://muller.lbl.gov/papers/Astrology-Carlson.pdf;最高人民检察院 (2026). 河南息县:历经三年持续追踪打掉一批网络算命诈骗团伙. https://www.spp.gov.cn/zdgz/202607/t20260728_732935.shtml
Open source linkBoth of these are just individual studies. The original paper by Forer does not directly state the average score; 4.26 was calculated based on the distribution of 1 as presented in the original text. This only states that 'it is inaccurate at prediction' and does not evaluate any belief. While spending a few dozen yuan for entertainment is fine, using it to decide on resignation, marriage, or investment is where the real financial loss lies.