22Evidence B

Don’t buy crystals, bracelets, or Pixiu figurines for “good luck,” “wealth attraction,” or “health benefits”

There is absolutely no verifiable evidence supporting claims that wearing such items can change one’s fate, attract wealth, or improve health. These assertions work on the same principle as fortune-telling: they are phrased so vaguely that people naturally interpret them as applying to themselves. In 2026, a livestream seller was investigated for false advertising after fabricating the materials used in its products and falsely claiming that they could prevent or treat rheumatism. Buying them as decorative accessories is fine.

Cost

There is no monetary cost involved. The only requirement i…

Benefit

Classic classroom experiments demonstrate that when participants receive the same generic “personality analysi…

Cost

There is no monetary cost involved. The only requirement is to avoid listing “good luck,” “health benefits,” or similar claims as reasons for purchase. The real challenge is resisting the urge to buy them when everyone else is wearing them and talking about their magical powers.

Benefit

Classic classroom experiments demonstrate that when participants receive the same generic “personality analysis,” they almost universally deem it accurate. This phenomenon is known as the Barnum effect, and it explains why many people feel that wearing these items somehow improves their lives. The underlying conclusion is simple: personal acceptance of a vague statement does not validate its factual accuracy. On June 4, 2026, China’s State Administration for Market Regulation published exemplary enforcement cases concerning traditional crafts, including a jewelry shop in Sihui, Guangdong. During livestream sales, the shop fabricated the materials used in its products and falsely advertised that its products could prevent rheumatism, boost immunity, improve sleep, and even clear blood vessels. By fabricating elaborate narratives, the business misled consumers, violating Article 9, Paragraph 1 of China’s Anti-Unfair Competition Law. The case was titled “Sihui Langzhen Jewelry Store False Commercial Promotion Case.”

Original sources

Forer BR (1949). The fallacy of personal validation: A classroom demonstration of gullibility. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0059240;国家市场监督管理总局 (2026). 市场监管总局公布一批传统工艺市场「打假清源」典型案例. https://www.samr.gov.cn/xw/zj/art/2026/art_1529399cfe874b8780c4496eb0158020.html

Open source link
Book note

There is only one conclusion: its effects cannot be checked, and no predictive power can be measured. This does not judge any belief or custom, and it does not target gifts, memorials, or heirlooms. Separate two things. Advertised medical effects have written rules and can be complained about. Claims like “luck” have no research and also cannot be proven false — you can only control them with a budget. Before buying, treat it as ordinary jewellery and ask: “If it changed nothing, would I still pay this price?” How to check materials and certificates, and why treating them as an investment does not pay: Section 5, Items 33 and 34 (count bracelets and watches as money already spent; for jewellery and jade accept only a CMA report). Paying for fortune-telling: Item 15 in this section (fortune-telling, tarot, horoscopes).

My note