24Evidence B

Don’t spend extra money to “move up a rung” among your peers by buying a new house, car, or social circle

Holding income equal, the more neighbours earn, the lower this person’s reported happiness. It mainly shows up with neighbours of the same education level, and more clearly in people who often deal with neighbours. So money spent to move into a place where everyone is better off than you buys moving yourself down a tier. But when incomes rise together, people still feel better off.

Cost

No cost at all. All you need to do is ask one extra questi…

Benefit

The National Survey of Family and Households (NSFH) in the U.S. surveyed the same individuals twice. Researche…

Cost

No cost at all. All you need to do is ask one extra question before increasing your budget: is this extra expense buying a real product, or simply securing a higher status among your peers? The difficulty lies in resisting the urge to upgrade when everyone else does.

Benefit

The National Survey of Family and Households (NSFH) in the U.S. surveyed the same individuals twice. Researchers matched these results with local average incomes calculated from a 5% sample of the 1990 census. After adjusting for personal characteristics and income, they found that higher neighbor incomes correlate strongly with lower self-reported happiness. This effect holds across multiple analytical methods and remains highly statistically significant. In fact, the drop in happiness caused by a rise in neighbor incomes matches the drop produced by a comparable fall in one’s own income. Even after controlling for individual-level factors or limiting comparisons to the same state and survey round, the pattern persists. This rules out explanations such as happier people naturally moving to poorer areas, unmeasured state-level variables, or differences between renters and homeowners. The effect is strongest among individuals with close neighbor ties, while those who socialize mainly outside their community show no such trend. Happiness declines only when comparing with neighbors of similar education; income differences among less educated neighbors have little impact. The mechanism appears to work mainly through satisfaction with one’s material circumstances rather than other life domains. Finally, when both personal and neighbor incomes rise proportionally, overall happiness still increases.

Original sources

Luttmer EFP (2005). Neighbors as Negatives: Relative Earnings and Well-Being. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 120(3), 963–1002. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/120.3.963;Luttmer EFP (2004). Neighbors as Negatives: Relative Earnings and Well-Being. NBER Working Paper No. 10667(本条引用的表述与数量级按这一版逐字核对). https://www.nber.org/papers/w10667

Open source link
Book note

Reasons for grade B: the data are repeated surveys of the same people, there is only this one study, and the sample is abroad. The outcome is self-reported happiness, not money. The authors did use statistics to drop several confounds — same person over time, same state and wave — but it is still not a randomized trial. There is no citeable counterpart for a Chinese population. Benefit magnitude is set to “medium,” following Item 23 in this section (don’t expect shopping to improve mood). The money saved may well reach the 10000-yuan level. But “how much happiness that saved money buys” has no number behind it, so it is not recorded as “large” on a 10000-yuan scale. This does not oppose spending for a larger home, a quieter compound, or a shorter commute — those buy the thing itself. What to stop is the single reason “colleagues all upgraded; I cannot fall behind.” How to rank a place to live: Section 4, Item 18 (put commute time first when choosing where to live). Buying things to regulate mood: Item 23 in this section. Constantly comparing upward online: Section 3, Item 20 (don’t treat “how others are doing” as required daily reading).

My note