41Evidence C

Drill holes to measure ice thickness before stepping onto it; don’t go out if it’s under 15 cm thick. Avoid ice over rivers and near ice-fishing holes

Official Chinese guidelines state that ice must be at least 15 cm thick before adults can safely skate on it. In the U.S. and Canada, the minimum threshold is 10 cm, but only for newly formed, transparent ice. White ice is only half as strong, so its thickness must be doubled to be considered safe. Even on the same body of water, ice can be 12 cm thick in one spot and just 2–3 cm a few steps away; therefore, you must measure it as you go.

Cost

The easiest and cheapest option is to visit a properly man…

Benefit

According to popular science explanations from the China Meteorological Administration, if the ice thickness r…

Cost

The easiest and cheapest option is to visit a properly managed public ice rink. If you must venture onto natural ice, bring an ice auger or ice chisel to measure thickness, plus a pair of rescue ice spikes — essentially two pointed spikes with handles that you can attach to your chest. Altogether, these items cost anywhere from a few dozen to a couple hundred yuan. You’ll need to measure the ice at regular intervals, which takes extra time.

Benefit

According to popular science explanations from the China Meteorological Administration, if the ice thickness reaches 15 cm, adults can go ice skating. Outdoor ice rinks must also reach 15 cm in thickness to open. The Beijing Municipal Water Authority states that regular natural ice rinks must have an ice thickness of 15 cm, and after that, temperatures must remain between -8°C and 1°C for the following week, with no strong winds for them to open. On wild ice, there are often ice holes drilled by people fishing, which are difficult to refreeze solidly once broken. The guidelines from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources in the United States only apply to newly formed clear ice: do not go on if it is less than 4 inches (approximately 10 cm); 4 inches is sufficient for walking and ice fishing. White ice, formed from snow melting and refreezing, has only about half the strength of clear ice, so its thickness must be calculated as double. On the same body of water, the ice might be one foot thick in one spot and only one or two inches a few feet away. Ice on flowing water is usually dangerous, especially near streams, bridges, and culverts. Ice near the shore may also be thinner than ice further out. The threshold provided by the United States National Weather Service for walking, ice fishing, and skating is also 4 inches. The Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety paraphrased recommendations from the Canadian Red Cross. For a few people skating or walking together, 15 cm is required, while for larger skating gatherings, 20 cm is required. These are all safety guidelines; no studies have calculated how many lives could be saved by following them (National / USA, Canada).

Original sources

中国气象局 (2019). 想要冰上健步走,多厚的冰才安全? https://www.cma.gov.cn/kppd/kppdqxyr/kppdtyqx/201901/t20190124_513302.html;北京市水务局 (2024). 北京正规河湖冰场还未达开放标准,别冒险滑「野冰」:「立春之后,随着气温回暖,冰面一天比一天薄,有些地方融化、渗水,随时有破裂的危险,所以立春之后不能上冰」「如果冰层的下部分看起来是丝丝的冰柱,就要特别注意,因为这些竖茬的冰说明冰层内部已经变酥」. https://swj.beijing.gov.cn/swdt/ztzl/fnsbaqztxc/fnszlxx/202412/t20241226_3973959.html;Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. General ice thickness guidelines. https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/safety/ice/thickness.html;Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Ice safety. https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/safety/ice/index.html;Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Steps for surviving immersion. https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/safety/ice/survival.html;National Weather Service. Winter Weather Safety: Ice and Frost. https://www.weather.gov/safety/winter-ice-frost;Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety. Working on or near Ice Covered Water - Basic Information. https://www.ccohs.ca/oshanswers/hsprograms/work_ice.html

Open source link
Book note

Official guidelines all state that there is no such thing as 100% safe ice; reaching the required thickness is merely a threshold, not a guarantee. The Beijing Municipal Water Authority states that after the Start of Spring, temperatures warm up, and the ice surface becomes thinner day by day; in some places, melting and seepage occur, meaning you cannot go on the ice after the Start of Spring. If the bottom half of the ice layer looks like thin, vertical ice pillars, it indicates the ice has become brittle; it may look thick but is dangerous. If you truly fall in, do not take off your clothes; the air trapped in thick clothing can help you float. Turn back toward the direction you came from, as the ice there is the most solid. Place your arms on the ice surface, drive an ice pick into the ice, kick your feet backward, and pull your body up. Once up, do not stand up immediately; roll away from the ice hole while lying flat, and then seek warmth as quickly as possible; if you are severely chilled, go to the hospital. If you see someone fall into an ice hole, do not run over to pull them; the method is described in Section 13, Item 25 (do not enter the water yourself when seeing someone drowning). First, call for help and dial 110, then extend a pole or throw a rope. The beneficiaries are primarily yourself and the children you bring to play on the ice.

My note