03Evidence B

Install smoke alarms; those heating with coal or gas in winter should also add a carbon monoxide alarm

With a working smoke alarm at home, deaths in residential fires are markedly less common. In 40% of US residential fires that caused deaths, someone was asleep when the fire started. If you burn coal or use gas indoors in winter, add a carbon monoxide alarm. In China, 11,500 people died from carbon monoxide poisoning in 2018; during the three winter months, about 70% of the deaths occurred at home.

Cost

A smoke alarm costs between 30 and 100 yuan. A carbon mono…

Benefit

A study in North Carolina examined homes that had experienced fires versus those that hadn’t. With a working s…

Cost

A smoke alarm costs between 30 and 100 yuan. A carbon monoxide alarm costs between 50 and 150 yuan. After installation, the batteries need to be replaced once a year.

Benefit

A study in North Carolina examined homes that had experienced fires versus those that hadn’t. With a working smoke alarm at home, deaths in fires were markedly less common. The odds ratio for death was 0.39 (OR 0.39), with a 95% confidence interval ranging from 0.18 to 0.83. Between 2018 and 2020, 24% of fatal residential fires in the U.S. happened in homes without smoke alarms, and 41% of these fatal fires began while someone was asleep. In 2018, China reported 11,523 deaths from carbon monoxide poisoning; among the deaths in each month, the proportion occurring at home was 72.59% in December, 67.42% in January, and 66.48% in February.

Original sources

Marshall SW 等 (1998). Fatal residential fires: who dies and who survives? JAMA. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.279.20.1633 ; USFA (2022). Fatal Fires in Residential Buildings (2018-2020), Topical Fire Report Series 22(2). https://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/statistics/v22i2.pdf ; You J 等 (2020). Number of Deaths due to Carbon Monoxide Poisoning by Month and by Place of Death — China, 2018. China CDC Weekly. https://doi.org/10.46234/ccdcw2020.008

Open source link
Book note

This grade is assigned because only one study exists on smoke alarms; it compared past fire incidents in various homes rather than using a randomized trial design. No research has shown that carbon monoxide alarms reduce mortality rates. The reported benefits are inferred from the fact that most poisoning deaths happen at home during winter.

Related products

All products

A few useful picks for this situation.

See JD for current prices and stock. Buying through these links helps support ongoing updates and improvements to this site.

My note