24Evidence A

Heavy smokers should get a low-dose chest CT once a year

Eligible heavy smokers undergo a low-dose CT scan once a year, and their probability of dying from lung cancer is 20.0% lower than those who only undergo chest X-rays. The overall probability of death is 6.7% lower. The cost is the follow-up examinations required after suspicious results are found, and the period of anxiety that follows.

Cost

The test costs 200–400 yuan per session and takes just 10…

Benefit

The US NLST randomized trial included 53,454 people, all of whom were aged 55 to 74, had a smoking history of…

Cost

The test costs 200–400 yuan per session and takes just 10 minutes. You must also factor in follow-up tests after any false alarms, plus the anxiety that comes with waiting for results.

Benefit

The US NLST randomized trial included 53,454 people, all of whom were aged 55 to 74, had a smoking history of 30 pack-years or more, and were current smokers or had quit no more than 15 years earlier. Pack-years is the unit used to measure smoking amount; smoking one pack a day for one year counts as one pack-year. The results are as follows: for those undergoing low-dose CT, the relative reduction in lung cancer mortality was 20.0% compared to those who only had chest X-rays. The 95% CI (confidence interval) is 6.8 to 26.7. The relative reduction in all-cause mortality was 6.7%, with a 95% CI of 1.2 to 13.6. With three consecutive years of screening, totaling three rounds, 24.2% of the low-dose CT results were suspicious. Among the suspicious results, 96.4% were false alarms (false positives).

Original sources

National Lung Screening Trial Research Team (2011). Reduced Lung-Cancer Mortality with Low-Dose Computed Tomographic Screening. New England Journal of Medicine:「The rate of positive screening tests was 24.2% with low-dose CT and 6.9% with radiography over all three rounds. A total of 96.4% of the positive screening results in the low-dose CT group and 94.5% in the radiography group were false positive results.」https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1102873

Open source link
Book note

This item only applies to high-risk smokers. In the same trial, 24.2% of the results from three rounds of low-dose CT were suspicious, of which 96.4% were false alarms (false positives). Non-smokers were not included in this trial, and whether screening provides benefits for them is a question this trial cannot answer.

My note