02Evidence A(争议)

Adding “education’s value” to mortality statistics: each extra year of schooling reduces adult mortality by roughly 1.9%

For every additional year of schooling, the average risk of dying in adulthood drops by about 1.9%. This effect is strongest among people aged 18–49, where the reduction is roughly 2.9% per extra year; for those over 70, it’s only 0.8%. Those who manage to stay in school tend to come from more privileged backgrounds, so it’s hard to isolate exactly how much of this benefit stems from education itself.

Cost

There is no monetary cost. The expense lies in the time an…

Benefit

This conclusion comes from a comprehensive meta-analysis that pooled findings from 603 separate studies conduc…

Cost

There is no monetary cost. The expense lies in the time and effort required to stay in school; tuition fees are covered under Section 4 of this chapter (vocational school tuition and grants). The real challenge is maintaining persistence — staying in school without dropping out.

Benefit

This conclusion comes from a comprehensive meta-analysis that pooled findings from 603 separate studies conducted in 70 locations across 59 countries between January 1980 and May 2023. There is a clear dose-response relationship between years of schooling and adult mortality (all causes combined): each extra year reduces mortality risk by an average of 1.9% (95% confidence interval: 1.8–2.0). For individuals aged 18–49, the reduction is 2.9% per year (2.8–3.0); for those over 70, it’s 0.8% (0.6–1.0). No significant gender differences were observed, nor did socioeconomic development level appear to influence the effect.

Original sources

IHME-CHAIN Collaborators (2024). Effects of education on adult mortality: a global systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet Public Health, 9(3), e155-e165. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2468-2667(23)00306-7

Open source link
Book note

Contested. The authors themselves reported publication bias (p<0.0001), meaning studies with nicer-looking results are more likely to be published. Results also differ widely across studies. All included work is follow-up observation, not trials that assign people to groups. Years of schooling are tangled with family circumstances, region, and occupation. Of this 1.9%, how much comes from schooling itself and how much from "people who can keep studying already had better circumstances" cannot be separated in this kind of study. Reverse causation cannot be separated either. People who were already ill or had mental problems as children are more likely to drop out and more likely to die early. That makes schooling look more useful than it is. So it strongly shows that "more schooling and living longer go the same way," but it does not equal "if you go to school you gain 1.9% more life." Benefit magnitude is set to small: what readers usually face is three or four more years; at 1.9% a year that adds up to under one tenth, which under this book's thresholds counts only as small. The beneficiary is you

My note