22Evidence A

Do not sell your organs or help find donors: the seller gets just over 20000 yuan for a kidney resold for 200000, and the proceeds are confiscated with a fine of 10 to 20 times the transaction amount

Living organs may be donated only to a spouse, direct blood relatives or collateral blood relatives within three generations; buying and selling are both illegal. In a Beijing case, kidney sellers received just over 20000 yuan, while the same kidney cost the patient 180000 to 220000 yuan. The proceeds are confiscated, followed by a fine of 10 to 20 times the transaction amount. For the physical cost of losing a kidney, see Section 1, item 35 (the remaining kidney does the work of two).

Cost

There’s no expense or time involved. All you have to do is…

Benefit

Article 5 of China’s Regulations on Human Organ Donation and Transplantation prohibits any organization or ind…

Cost

There’s no expense or time involved. All you have to do is simply refrain from doing it.

Benefit

Article 5 of China’s Regulations on Human Organ Donation and Transplantation prohibits any organization or individual from buying or selling human organs in any form or engaging in related activities. Article 10 prohibits obtaining living organs from citizens under 18 for transplantation. Article 11 limits recipients of living organs to the donor’s spouse, direct blood relatives or collateral blood relatives within three generations. Article 37 sets the penalties for buying or selling organs and related activities, investigated by health authorities of local governments at county level or above. First, all illegal proceeds from the transaction are confiscated. A fine of 10 to 20 times the transaction amount is then imposed. Participating medical personnel lose their practice certificates and are barred for life from providing medical and health services. Conduct constituting a crime incurs criminal liability. These rules apply throughout China from May 1, 2024; the former Regulations on Human Organ Transplantation were repealed at the same time. Article 234-1 of the Criminal Law provides up to five years in prison and a fine for organizing others to sell human organs; serious cases bring at least five years and a fine or confiscation of property. Three further situations are punished under Articles 234 and 232: removing organs without the person’s consent, removing organs from someone under eighteen, or forcing or deceiving someone into donating. These are treated as intentional injury or intentional homicide. Case one: on August 20, 2014, the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People’s Court issued the final judgment in the case of Zheng Wei and 14 others, 15 defendants in total. It involved 51 kidneys and more than 10340000 yuan. Kidney sellers, the donors, received only 20000 to 25000 yuan each. Patients awaiting kidneys, the recipient side, paid 180000 or 190000 yuan per kidney earlier, and 210000 or 220000 later. The removal site was a four-story building rented for 7500 yuan a month. The group’s head nurse testified that it was filthy and did not even have resuscitation equipment. Organizer Zheng Wei received 12 years for organizing the sale of human organs; the other 14 received three and a half to nine years. Case two: the Supreme People’s Procuratorate published the case of a teenager selling a kidney to buy an Apple phone. Wang, aged 17, had his right kidney removed in Chenzhou on the evening of April 28, 2011. The operation used premises supplied by a privately contracted department within a hospital that had no transplantation qualification. On discharge on May 2 he received 22000 yuan. The recipient side paid the intermediary 150000 yuan and 10000 US dollars; the principal offender profited by more than 56000 yuan. Wang developed renal insufficiency after surgery; his injury was classified as serious and as grade-three disability.

Original sources

国务院 (2023). 人体器官捐献和移植条例(国务院令第 767 号,第五、八、十、十一、二十三、二十八、二十九、三十七条). https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/202312/content_6920196.htm;全国人大常委会. 中华人民共和国刑法(经刑法修正案十一修正的整合文本)第二百三十四条之一. https://flk.npc.gov.cn/detail?id=ff808181796a636a0179822a19640c92;最高人民检察院 (2012-04-09). 「少年卖肾买苹果手机」案诉至法院. https://www.spp.gov.cn/gs/201204/t20120409_34342.shtml;河北省廊坊市中级人民法院官网转载 (2014-09-02). 全国最大贩肾案终审 组织者摘肾 51 枚获利千万. https://lfzy.hebeicourt.gov.cn/article/detail/2014/09/id/1430881.shtml

Open source link
Book note

The beneficiary is you. What looks like receiving twenty thousand yuan in one payment is actually exchanging an organ for a phone. The teenager’s injury was assessed as serious injury and grade-three disability; a few months of rest would not fix it. Prosecutors charged five defendants with intentional injury under Article 234, paragraph 2. One reason was that medical personnel removed the right kidney without first checking whether the donor was a minor. If the same conduct occurred today, recruiters would face the offense of organizing the sale of human organs, while removing an organ from someone under eighteen would still be punished as intentional injury under Article 234. Illegal brokers operate in rented housing or borrowed premises, with no assessment beyond tissue matching and no postoperative follow-up; if complications arise, there is nobody to hold accountable. If you genuinely want to donate to a relative, follow Article 11: use a medical institution qualified for transplantation, undergo ethics-committee review and receive no payment at any stage. Posthumous organ donation is unpaid and outside this item. For the bodily cost after losing a kidney, see Section 1, item 35 (the remaining kidney does the work of two). If money is so short that you are considering selling an organ, first see Section 7’s assistance channels: unemployment insurance, temporary assistance and minimum-living assistance. Online loans and loans using fabricated or dressed-up application materials are covered in item 6 of this section.

My note