24Evidence A

Translating comics into Chinese, reposting films and series, and sharing cloud resources or pirated e-books infringes copyright even for free; ads or membership fees can make it a crime

Translating and posting someone else’s work without permission, or uploading it, infringes copyright even if you charge nothing: you must remove it and compensate the loss. Ads or membership fees establish a profit-making purpose. Illegal income of at least 30000 yuan, at least 500 works shared, or at least 1000 registered members can meet a criminal threshold; the maximum sentence is 10 years. The head of the Renren Yingshi subtitle group received 3 years and 6 months.

Cost

There’s virtually no cost involved. You can buy or downloa…

Benefit

First, civil liability under Chinese law. Copyright includes translation rights, the right to convert a work f…

Cost

There’s virtually no cost involved. You can buy or download content for personal viewing or translation practice, as long as you don’t post it online for others to access. Avoid creating resource websites or groups that display ads or charge membership fees, and never sell cloud storage links. The real challenge is resisting the urge to become a “reposter” when everyone else seems to be doing it.

Benefit

First, civil liability under Chinese law. Copyright includes translation rights, the right to convert a work from one written language into another, and the right of communication through information networks, allowing the public to access a work online anywhere and anytime. Translating without permission is infringement; uploading without permission is also infringement. The infringer must stop and compensate losses. Only using another person’s published work for personal study, research or appreciation does not require permission or payment. Compensation is first based on the rightsholder’s actual loss or your earnings. If neither can be established, the court sets 500 to 5000000 yuan. Intentional infringement in serious circumstances can bring compensation of 1 to 5 times the relevant amount. You must also cover reasonable costs incurred by the rightsholder to stop the infringement. Next, criminal liability. Article 217 of the Criminal Law requires a profit-making purpose. Uploading others’ works for public access without permission to make money constitutes the offense once a threshold is reached. It brings up to 3 years in prison and a fine, or a fine alone; huge amounts or especially serious circumstances bring 3 to 10 years and a fine. Profit-making includes selling, paid advertising on a webpage, and membership systems charging registration or other fees. Service, membership and advertising fees all count as illegal income. Any one of these thresholds is enough: illegal income of at least 30000 yuan; illegal business volume of at least 50000 yuan, which in the Renren Yingshi case included all membership fees, advertising fees and hard-drive sales; at least 500 works disseminated online; at least 10000 downloads or 100000 clicks; or at least 1000 registered members in a membership distribution system. If none is fully reached but two each reach at least half, that also qualifies. Reaching 10 times these figures puts the case in the 3-to-10-year band. A fine is generally 1 to 10 times illegal income. Official case one: Liang Yongping and others downloaded unauthorized films and series from overseas websites, organized translation and subtitling, and uploaded them to the Renren Yingshi subtitle-group website and app for streaming and downloading. There were 32824 unauthorized works and more than 6830000 members. From January 2018 to January 2021 they collected over 2700000 yuan in membership fees and over 8800000 in advertising fees; portable hard drives containing films and series brought over 1000000 more. A donation QR code provided membership benefits to donors. Prosecutors regarded that as membership fees under another name. On November 22, 2021, Liang received 3 years and 6 months and a 1500000-yuan fine. Another 14 defendants received suspended sentences of 1 year and 6 months to 3 years, and fines of 40000 to 350000 yuan. Official case two: Ke used crawling software to collect playback addresses for more than 50000 films and series and offered them free on his website and app. Launch-screen advertisements paid by impressions earned him more than 350000 yuan. In 2023 he received 3 years in prison, suspended for 4 years, and a 400000-yuan fine. Official case three: Huang rented a server at home and set up a music-download forum. He uploaded more than 100000 songs to 18 cloud drives and posted links in the forum. Members had to buy forum coins to obtain the links and access codes; top-ups totaled more than 500000 yuan. In 2023 he received 3 years in prison, suspended for 4 years, and a 550000-yuan fine. This applies throughout China; the judicial interpretation took effect on April 26, 2025.

Original sources

全国人大常委会 (2020). 著作权法(2020 年修正,第十条第一款第十二、十五项,第二十四条第一项,第五十二条第六项,第五十三条第一项,第五十四条). http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/c2/c30834/202011/t20201119_308796.html;全国人大常委会 (2020). 刑法修正案(十一)(第二十项,即刑法第二百一十七条). https://www.spp.gov.cn/zdgz/202012/t20201227_503682.shtml;最高人民法院、最高人民检察院 (2025). 关于办理侵犯知识产权刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释(法释〔2025〕5 号,第十二、十三、二十五、二十八、三十一条). https://www.spp.gov.cn/xwfbh/wsfbt/202504/t20250424_693977.shtml;最高人民法院、最高人民检察院、公安部 (2011). 关于办理侵犯知识产权刑事案件适用法律若干问题的意见(法发〔2011〕3 号,第十条). https://www.dongguandesq.jcy.gov.cn/tzgg/201103/t20110321_3344314.shtml(东莞市第二市区人民检察院转载);最高人民检察院 (2023). 第四十八批指导性案例(检例第 193 号,梁永平、王正航等十五人侵犯著作权案). https://www.spp.gov.cn/spp/jczdal/202309/t20230915_628229.shtml;最高人民检察院 (2024). 检察机关依法惩治侵犯著作权犯罪典型案例(案例一、案例三). https://www.spp.gov.cn/spp/xwfbh/wsfbt/202401/t20240105_639347.shtml;中国驻长崎总领事馆 (2018). 中国驻长崎总领事馆提醒在日中国公民遵守著作权法. http://nagasaki.china-consulate.gov.cn/chn/tzgg/201802/t20180208_4564322.htm

Open source link
Book note

The beneficiary is you. Buying to watch yourself, or translating for yourself, is within what the statute allows. The line is “putting it online for everyone to see.” Subtitle and fan-translation groups that do not charge do not meet the crime of infringing copyright, because that crime requires a profit purpose. Civil infringement still stands; rightsholders can demand takedown and compensation. In Japan, not charging can still be unlawful. In February 2018 several Chinese citizens in Japan were arrested on suspicion of violating Japanese copyright law. The Chinese consulate-general in Nagasaki then reminded: translating, publishing, or disseminating works without authorization may be unlawful even without profit. Once you hang ads, open memberships, or trade “donations” for membership benefits, you fall into the for-profit band. In the Renren Yingshi case, people who only translated or proofread and took little part were treated as witnesses by police. The Supreme People’s Procuratorate wrote in that case that those who start it, divide the money, and run the platform should be pursued strictly. Hired accomplices may receive more lenient treatment; those brought in temporarily with light circumstances may not face criminal liability. The old 2004, 2007, and 2020 intellectual-property criminal judicial interpretations were repealed from 26 April 2025. The 2011 three-agency opinion was not named for repeal; where it conflicts with the new interpretation, the new one controls. For example the click threshold changed from 50000 (5万) to 100000 (10万). Another risk of writing fan works or derivatives for publication is in item 25 of this section (writing fan works). Printing others’ images on goods to sell is in Section 12, item 21 (buy a license for patterns). What to do when you run a platform and get a rightsholder’s infringement notice is in Section 26, item 9 (receiving an infringement notice).

My note