02Evidence A

Do not make or sell game cheats and assistance tools, including AI assistance that “only reads the screen and never touches memory,” or modified software that adds features to apps such as WeChat

Selling to just 20 users or earning 5,000 yuan is enough to qualify as “serious circumstances,” leading to a sentence of up to three years. In especially serious cases the penalty ranges from three to seven years. One developer who created aim‑assist and wall‑hack cheats sold them over 80,000 times in three months, netting more than 30,000 yuan; he received a one‑year suspended sentence plus a 5,000‑yuan fine. Another individual obtained the game’s server code, ran a private server, and collected over 20 million yuan in payments; he was sentenced to four years in prison and fined up to 10 million yuan.

Cost

There is no monetary cost. The trade‑off is giving up pote…

Benefit

Providing programs or tools specially used to intrude upon or illegally control computer information systems,…

Cost

There is no monetary cost. The trade‑off is giving up potential income from such orders and “small tools.” The difficulty lies in the fact that this money comes quickly and it’s unclear who might eventually pursue legal action.

Benefit

Providing programs or tools specially used to intrude upon or illegally control computer information systems, when circumstances are serious, brings up to 3 years and a fine concurrently or alone. Concurrent means prison plus a fine; alone means fine only. Especially serious circumstances bring 3 to 7 years plus a fine. The threshold for “serious circumstances” is providing the tool to 20 person-times or more, or illegal gains of 5000 yuan or more. Illegal gains means the money earned from this. Intentionally bypassing or destroying technical protection measures set by the rights holder may also constitute copyright infringement, with up to 3 years, or 3 to 10 years in serious cases. Official case: Wang and others made and sold cheats that read and modified game memory for wall hacks and aim assist. In 3 months they sold over 80000 yuan and profited over 30000 yuan. Sentence: 1 year suspended for 1 year, fine 5000 yuan. Suspended for 1 year means a 1-year sentence that is not served yet; if you stay clean that year you need not go to prison. Xiang and others sold the “TZ” series of cheats with sales over 200000 yuan; Xiang got 3 years suspended for 3 years and a 20000 yuan fine. Liu and others obtained game server programs, changed parameters, ran private servers, and took over 20000000 yuan in top-ups. Sentences from 4 years to 2 years 6 months, fines from 10000000 to 1300000 yuan. Not only games. A Shanghai company made custom ROMs that added dozens of features to WeChat on the phone — auto-forward, like, mass message, and more. Those phones were sold as “marketing phones,” 2381 units. In 2019 the Shanghai Xuhui court convicted the company of copyright infringement, fined it 500000 yuan, and sentenced the person in charge to 1 year 6 months suspended for 1 year 6 months (nationwide)

Original sources

全国人大 (2020). 刑法(根据刑法修正案(十一)修正,第二百八十五条第三款、第二百一十七条第六项). https://jtgl.beijing.gov.cn/jgj/jgxx/flfg/fl/11033925/index.html;最高人民法院、最高人民检察院 (2011). 关于办理危害计算机信息系统安全刑事案件应用法律若干问题的解释(第三条). https://ga.sz.gov.cn/ZWGK/ZCFG/ZCJD/content/post_1304363.html(深圳市公安局转载);最高人民检察院 (2026). 上海静安:严惩制售游戏外挂黑灰产共护清朗网络空间. https://www.spp.gov.cn/spp/zdgz/202608/t20260825_735480.shtml;最高人民检察院 (2021). 2020 年度检察机关保护知识产权典型案例(案例五). https://www.spp.gov.cn/spp/xwfbh/wsfbt/202104/t20210425_516525.shtml;国家版权局 (2020). 2019 年度上海十大版权典型案件发布(上海市版权局发布,案例八:上海昱宫网络科技有限公司等侵犯著作权案). https://www.ncac.gov.cn/xxfb/ywxx/202004/t20200430_47269.html

Open source link
Book note

All published cheat‑related rulings involve programs that read or modify game memory and circumvent anti‑cheat systems. No official cases have yet addressed aids that merely capture screenshots or simulate keystrokes. Nevertheless, a recent ticket‑scaling case shows that even tools that do not touch memory but merely send requests can be deemed illegal data‑acquisition tools. Whether an act qualifies as a crime and which charge applies is determined by law‑enforcement agencies based on evidence supplied by game developers, not by the author’s interpretation. The requirement of just 20 users to meet the “serious circumstances” threshold is quite low.

My note