11Evidence A

Tie your money to your commitment — but first ask if you’re willing to pay

A randomized trial involving 2,538 participants compared two incentive models: one offering a cash reward for success, and another requiring an upfront deposit that is refunded plus a bonus only if the goal is met. Among those willing to join either program, the deposit model produced a success rate 13 percentage points higher than the reward model. Yet only 13.7% of participants agreed to pay the deposit, while 90% opted for the reward option. Thus the deposit approach works best for those willing to pay; for everyone else it essentially has no effect.

Cost

Under this deposit‑based approach, participants must put u…

Benefit

In a U.S. trial with 2,538 participants, employees and their relatives were randomly assigned to one of four i…

Cost

Under this deposit‑based approach, participants must put up their own cash upfront; if they fail to meet the target, the money is forfeited. In this trial, the required deposit was $150.

Benefit

In a U.S. trial with 2,538 participants, employees and their relatives were randomly assigned to one of four incentive schemes or standard care. The reward model (earning roughly $800 for success) attracted 90.0% participation, whereas the deposit model (requiring a $150 upfront payment plus a $650 bonus) attracted just 13.7%. After six months, overall quit rates ranged from 9.4% to 16.0% across all incentive groups, compared with 6.0% under standard care. The reward model yielded a 15.7% quit rate, while the deposit model produced 10.2%. However, when looking only at the 13.7% of participants willing to pay the deposit, the deposit model achieved a six‑month quit rate 13.2 percentage points higher than the reward model (95% CI 3.1–22.8, a reliable range).

Original sources

Halpern SD, French B, Small DS, et al. (2015). Randomized trial of four financial-incentive programs for smoking cessation. New England Journal of Medicine, 372(22), 2108–2117. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1414293

Open source link
Book note

This trial measured quitting smoking. Moving it to writing a paper, exercising, and similar tasks is an inference, so the benefit size is marked moderate. When you choose a plan, first look at whether you will actually use it, not at which one is more effective. A method most people will not accept, however strong the effect, does nothing for those people. So first pick the kind you are willing to accept. Staking a smaller amount is still better than staking nothing. How to quit smoking itself is in section 2, item 3 (medicine for quitting smoking).

My note