08Evidence B

For quick relief on the spot, try the 5‑minute “cyclic sigh”: two inhalations followed by a prolonged exhalation

In a one‑month controlled trial where participants performed each of three breathing exercises for 5 minutes daily, all three proved more effective than an equal amount of mindfulness meditation at lifting mood and lowering respiratory rate. The “cyclic sigh” — which emphasizes lengthening the exhale — performed best. The method is simple: inhale once through the nose, then take a brief second inhale to fully fill the lungs, and finally exhale slowly through the mouth. This particular study relied on self‑reported data and involved a relatively small group of volunteers, yet it required zero expense.

Cost

No cost at all. Just 5 minutes a day.

Benefit

This home‑based, randomized controlled trial compared three distinct 5‑minute daily breathing routines — cycli…

Cost

No cost at all. Just 5 minutes a day.

Benefit

This home‑based, randomized controlled trial compared three distinct 5‑minute daily breathing routines — cyclic sighing (focused on extended exhalation), box breathing (equal durations of inhale, hold, and exhale), and cyclic hyperventilation with pauses — against an equivalent mindfulness meditation regimen over a month. Using a mixed‑effects model on pooled data, each breathing technique outperformed meditation; cyclic sighing stood out for its superior impact on mood improvement (statistically significant at P<0.05) and on reducing breathing frequency (also P<0.05).

Original sources

Balban MY, Neri E, Kogon MM, et al. (2023). Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Reports Medicine, 4(1), 100895. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xcrm.2022.100895

Open source link
Book note

The method is to inhale once through the nose, briefly add 1 more small breath to fill the lungs, then breathe the air out slowly and at length through the mouth, and repeat for 5 minutes. There is only this 1 trial. It was done at home, whether it helped was reported by the person on a questionnaire, and the number of people was not large. The effect is only slightly better than meditation. It does not amount to solving the problem. But it costs nothing, takes only 5 minutes, and can be done anytime, anywhere, so the return for the cost is high.

My note