20Evidence A

Before opening an individual pension account, calculate the tax saving and check withdrawal conditions; do not contribute only for a deduction if you pay no income tax or are in the 3% band

A full 12000-yuan contribution deducted entirely within the 10%, 20% or 30% band gives a net tax difference of 840, 2040 or 3240 yuan. This already subtracts the 3% withdrawal tax; recalculate if the deduction crosses bands. In the 3% band, the tax saved is paid back on withdrawal, at best breaking even. Do not deposit money you may need at any time: early withdrawal is limited to specified medical, unemployment and subsistence-support circumstances.

Cost

Opening is free, but contributions cannot be withdrawn at…

Benefit

Actual contributions, up to 12000 yuan annually, can be deducted from comprehensive or business income. Invest…

Cost

Opening is free, but contributions cannot be withdrawn at will. Besides reaching the age for receiving a basic pension, qualifying medical spending, unemployment and subsistence-support conditions allow withdrawal; see the note for thresholds. Without eligibility, you may still have to wait many years.

Benefit

Actual contributions, up to 12000 yuan annually, can be deducted from comprehensive or business income. Investment income within the account is temporarily exempt from individual income tax; withdrawals are taxed separately at 3%, not included in comprehensive income. Calculate the current-year saving as annual tax before the deduction minus annual tax afterward. A deduction may cross into a lower band, so multiplying the contribution by the current marginal rate is not always valid. The marginal rate is the rate on each additional yuan earned. For example, after other deductions, annual taxable comprehensive income before contributing is 40000 yuan, with tax of 1480 yuan. Contributing and deducting 12000 yuan lowers taxable income to 28000 yuan and tax to 840 yuan, saving 640 yuan that year. Ignoring investment returns and the time value of money, withdrawing this 12000-yuan principal later incurs 360 yuan tax, leaving a net tax difference of 280 yuan. Only when the full 12000-yuan deduction stays in one band can that rate be used to calculate the current saving. Again considering only principal, without investment returns or time value, the 10%, 20% and 30% bands give net differences of 840, 2040 and 3240 yuan. These are tax differences at different times, not investment returns, and cannot simply be divided by years to create an annualized yield. People who pay no income tax save nothing now but still pay 3% on withdrawal. For those in the 3% band, the current saving is no more than 3% of the contribution. This band applies when annual taxable comprehensive income after deductions does not exceed 36000 yuan. Considering principal alone and ignoring time value, the saving does not exceed the later tax on that principal; a deduction alone does not establish value. Monthly withholding does not mean the annual rate is 10%. Contribution limits accumulate by calendar year, with no carry-forward of unused amounts. The system became nationwide on December 15, 2024. From September 1, 2025, qualifying medical spending, receipt of unemployment benefits and subsistence support also permit early withdrawal. Without meeting a condition, money is not freely accessible, so this is unsuitable for emergency funds you may need at any time (China nationwide).

Original sources

财政部、税务总局 (2024). 关于在全国范围实施个人养老金个人所得税优惠政策的公告(财政部 税务总局公告 2024 年第 21 号,2024 年 12 月 12 日). https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c102416/c5237110/content.html;人力资源社会保障部等五部门 (2022). 个人养老金实施办法(第七、八、九、十二、十三条). https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2022-11/05/content_5724783.htm;全国人民代表大会常务委员会 (2018). 中华人民共和国个人所得税法(2018 年第七次修正,个人所得税税率表一). http://www.npc.gov.cn/zgrdw/npc/xinwen/2018-09/05/content_2060671.htm;人力资源社会保障部等五部门 (2025). 关于领取个人养老金有关问题的通知(人社部发〔2025〕39 号,第一、二、三、七项). https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c100013/c5242402/content.html

Open source link
Book note

There are six withdrawal conditions: reaching basic-pension eligibility age, complete loss of working capacity, settlement abroad or outside mainland China, and the following three. For medical spending, examine the 12 months before application: eligible out-of-pocket costs for yourself, your spouse or minor children, within the covered list after medical-insurance reimbursement, must total more than the province’s previous-year per-capita disposable income. For unemployment, receipt of unemployment-insurance benefits must total 12 months within the preceding 2 years. Subsistence support requires currently receiving the urban or rural minimum-living allowance. If any condition is met, apply for verification through the account bank, national social-security service platform or other channels. Funds already invested in products must also follow those products’ rules. Do not put emergency funds here; see item 27. Value also depends on when you need the money, product returns, fees and risk, not tax savings alone. You choose the investments yourself, and some products can lose money. See items 17 and 18 on broad-market index funds and low fees. The individual pension information-management service platform issues deduction certificates. Salary and other income subject to cumulative withholding can claim the deduction during current-year withholding or the following year’s annual reconciliation. Other income claims it at the following year’s reconciliation under the rules; see item 2.

My note