15Evidence A

Infrequent stock trading

US households that traded most frequently in the 1990s earned only 11.4% annually, compared to 17.9% for the entire market during the same period; the gap was mainly due to transaction costs. In China's 2014–2015 period of extreme volatility, the smallest 85% of households traded too frequently. They earned 250 billion yuan less than those who simply held their positions, which is approximately 30% of their initial capital.

Cost

There are no monetary costs. The real challenge is resisti…

Benefit

This study examines 66,465 household accounts of US discount brokers from 1991 to 1996. The group with the mos…

Cost

There are no monetary costs. The real challenge is resisting the urge to trade whenever you see market news.

Benefit

This study examines 66,465 household accounts of US discount brokers from 1991 to 1996. The group with the most frequent trading saw an annualized return of 11.4%, meaning they earned an average of 11.4% per year. During the same period, the entire market was 17.9%, and the average household was 16.4%. The average annual turnover rate for a household was 75%, meaning they replaced three-quarters of their stocks in one year. The difference in gross returns (earnings before deducting fees) between the frequent trading group and the infrequent trading group was very small. Therefore, the gap primarily stems from the transaction costs paid during buying and selling (USA, 1991 to 1996). Domestic data: The study uses daily account data from the Shanghai Stock Exchange, covering all approximately 40 million accounts. The sample period is from July 2014 to December 2015, totaling 18 months. During these 18 months, the Shanghai Composite Index rose by over 150% first. It peaked at 5166.35 points on June 12, 2015, and fell by 40% by the end of December. Household accounts are divided into four tiers based on their market value at the beginning of the period. The smallest tier accounts for 85% of all household accounts, while the largest tier accounts for 0.5%. The total market value of stocks for the two tiers was similar, at 880 billion yuan and 808 billion yuan, respectively. The result was that the smallest 85% lost 250 billion yuan due to active trading, while the largest 0.5% earned 254 billion yuan. Here, 'loss' is compared to holding positions without any action during the same market period. Each figure is approximately equivalent to 30% of the group's initial stock market value, specifically 28% for the former and 31% for the latter. As a control, the market was relatively calm for the two and a half years prior to June 2014. During any 18-month period in that time, the similar difference was only 1% to 3% of the initial market value. In this market cycle, household accounts replaced their stocks on average about every three weeks, nearly 18 times a year (Shanghai, China, 2014 to 2015; control period 2012 to 2014).

Original sources

Barber BM, Odean T (2000). Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth: The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors. The Journal of Finance 55(2):773-806. https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00226;An L, Lou D, Shi D (2022). Wealth redistribution in bubbles and crashes. Journal of Monetary Economics 126:134-153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmoneco.2022.01.001;同文作者公开的工作论文稿(2021 年 10 月,国内数字按它逐字核对). https://personal.lse.ac.uk/loud/AnLouShi.pdf

Open source link
Book note

The US data is from the 1990s, and the commission and stamp duty structure for A-shares is different; however, the principle that 'higher turnover leads to lower net returns' remains the same. This is not advising you not to buy stocks, nor does the domestic study suggest so. It calculates that during the same market period, the more actively small-account households trade, the more money flows into the hands of the party on the other side of their trades. The ones taking this money are not institutions, but the individual investors with the largest accounts: during this period, approximately 90% of the SSE trading volume came from retail accounts, and Table 1 of the paper shows 87% of daily trading volume. The circulating claim that '90% of retail investors lose money' cannot be verified with official statistics, so this item does not use that figure. Turnover rates can be compared: in this market cycle, domestic household accounts traded nearly 18 times a year, while the US group only replaced three-quarters of their stocks in a year. In calm years, this domestic gap was only one to three percent, so the time one should most exercise restraint is during the hottest market periods. This does not constitute investment advice.

My note